FILM
- AS A -
SUBVERSIVE ART



LIFE WITH VIDEO
(William Walker, USA. 1972)
A TV personality, without leaving the set, makes
very personal contact with a willing viewer,
finally disappearing into her (via a ladder).
Being told, in a muffled voice, that he will now
be with her "always", she moans voluptuously,
her confusion between TV and reality complete.
Do we not all wish for similar confusion?


STRAINING TOWARDS THE LIMITS


THE ELIMINATION OF REALITY

A beautiful and true story is told of the abstract painter Frank
Kubka.  In the course of a walk, he apologized to nature for
having attempted to copy her and promised not to do so again.  (1)

There have always existed in the plastic arts tendencies towards
forms and images undefiled by representations of reality. This can
be seen in Neolithic abstractions, Egyptian designs and Indian
patterns, Byzantine artifacts and Renaissance concerns with
structure and design.  In our day, having removed reality from
the image, attempts are being made to remove the image itself.

In 1898, the young Munich art nouveau
architect August Endell foresaw this:

We stand at the threshold of an altogether new art,
an art with forms which mean or represent nothing,
recall nothing, yet which can stimulate our souls as
deeply as only the tones of music have been able to. 
(2)

There could be no better definition of the aims and aspirations of abstract
art.  It was an art, as Herbert Read wrote, that was to echo basic laws and
structures of the universe, "liberated from the tyranny of appearances";
an "objective" investigation of colors, shapes, lines, and visual rhythms
in order to create force patterns capable of evoking emotions and feelings.

Elements of three tendencies converged in abstract art; the surrealist and
dadaist heritage expressed in abstract shapes related to the subconcious
(Arp, Miro, Klee, the Eggeling-Richter films Diagonale Symphonie and
Rhythmus 21, and Jackson Pollock's "automatic painting"):  the romantic
realism of Gauguin, Matisse, and the Fauvists which led to the "hot",
sensuous abstractions of Kandinski; and the cubist attempts to
reduce objects to their essence, which connected Cezanne, Picasso,
and Braque to the "cool", meticulous abstractions of Mondrian.

It has proven difficult to maintain the objective stance of abstract
art in practice:  even the simplest lines exude psychological vibra-
tions or else come dangerously close to symbolism. Piet Mondrian
found it entirely "comprehensible that some abstract artists have
objected to the name Abstract Art.  Abstract Art is concrete and,
by its determined means of expression, even more concrete than
naturalistic art."  (3)  And it was Rudolf Arnheim who called non-
objective patterns "the very elements of visual comprehension,
the building stones of the composition the artist creates in order
to represent the structure of the world in the way his temperament
makes him see it".  (4)   It is thus possible to refer to abstract artists
as the true realists of our technological period, who, far from retreating
from the world, have merely stepped back for a fuller view.  But reality
came under attack in other ways:  the cubist "reduction" extended
to collages of found objects and photo  montages, cut up and
degraded  until reality was atomized or no longer recognizable.
___________________________________________________________________________________________

FOR EXAMPLE
(S. Arakawa, USA, 1971)   (F)
A feature-length documentary of a boy drunkard,
photographed on New York's Bowery, as a coldly
detached camera records his daily life in the streets.
Does it matter if he is "real" or "only" an actor? There
exists, says the filmmaker, a child such as this some-
where and his life can be documented before he is found.
______________________________________________

This work by Arakawa, the Japanese conceptual artist responsible
for Why Not, is equally original and even more subversive. Here
reality itself -- the truth of  the image -- is insidiously called into
question.  Feature-length, this is a coldly objective record of
a 7-year-old child derelict, totally alone, living as a  drunkard
on New York's Bowery.  The ruthless yet compassionate camera
explores his world, often in oppressive "real time", following
his every degradation and defeat (including his attempts to stop
indifferent passers-by) until a traumatic, catatonic seizure in a
telephone booth; a searing, terrifying sequence.  But the metaphy-
sical twist is still to come:  the documentary is not a documentary,
the child drunkard "only" an actor.  But, says Arakawa, there exists
a child such as this somewhere; hence his portrayal in real streets of
such blight that  they resemble cityscapes destroyed by war, is "true":
"This is a willful switch from the documentary as a 'truthful' account
to a new form, one which employs the weight of  evidence, the pace
of reality only as an impetus or format for the onset of a cinema of
investigation,an investigation which the filmmaker has willed
to exist.  As such, it is as much a new reality as a new "story".

___________________________________________________________________________________________

THE SUBVERSION OF ILLUSIONISM

If the arts subvert by providing "illusionist" representations of
revolt or perfection, there is no reason why the illusion of art
cannot itself be subverted.  It is here that the structuralist cinema
of our day makes its most disruptive contribution:  it forces the
artwork to reveal its own superficiality, drawing our attention to
its hitherto jealously concealed, "fraudulent" character.  Vertov's
The Man With a Movie Camera, with its manipulation of different
levels of reality, may have initiated this in cinema; the contemporary
structuralist avant-garde continues it. In their works, we often see
the real photographer and his equipment, actors "stepping out of role"
to address the audience, clapboards and mikes, academy leaders, splice
marks and sprocket holes, in direct violation of the illusion of film space.
___________________________________________________________________________________________

VIRGINITY
(Roberto Rosselini, episode in Rogopag, Italy, 1962)   (F)
The "reality" of the flat, two-dimensional screen --
secret repository of our deepest dreams -- is here
revelled in by a love-struck man who projects
moving images of his beloved onto his body and
attempts to caress them; but films come to an end and
there is pathos in his unrequited, twice removed passion.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

THE ELIMINATION OF THE IMAGE

The silent cinema -- entirely dependent on images --
created works of sublime visual intensity:  it was
perhaps inevitable that subversive artists of our
day should attack the notion of the image itself.

Contributing to this trend has been the increasing incursion
of brief (then longer) scenes of darkness or light into experi-
mental films, accompanied by sound or, more potently, silence:
extreme pop-art collages that shred reality into fragments:
and the preoccupation of abstract artists and minimalists with
vision and pure light.  The  elimination of the image in the films
of Kubelka, Sharits, and Conrad has led to the study of light
as the "subject" of art, paralleling investigations of pigment
and  surface in conceptual painting. But by robbing a visual
art of its visuals, these artists are revealed as subversives.
___________________________________________________________________________________________

DEAD MOVIE
(Taka Iimura, USA, 1968)
Projectors and blank screen as metaphysical
monsters, a performance of Iimura's Dead Movie --
face to face projections of two 16mm projectors;
one projects a white frame (without film),
the other projects black leader in an endless loop.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

THE ELIMINATION OF THE SCREEN

The conventional, two-dimensional screen surface of cinema's
first hundred years is also under attack by holography,
a sensational recent development in the visual field.
 This is the production of a 3-dimensional "image" in
space by means of a laser whose light-wave emissions
(bouncing off the subject being holographed) are captured
on a photo-sensitive surface without passing through
lenses and projected in space.  (5) Short holographic films --
viewable without special glasses -- already exist.  The future
presages  life-size 3-dimensional holographic motion pic-
tures, through and around which the viewer will be able to
pass -- a probably boon to film art as well as pornography.

Youngblood points to the ability of holography to record
natural phenomena beyond the range of human perception --
shockwaves, electrical vibrations, ultra-slow motion events --
thereby contributing to the experiencing of non-ordinary
realities beyond the range of conventional cinema.  (6)
___________________________________________________________________________________________

MOTHLIGHT
(Stan Brakhage, USA, 1961)
Limbs, wings, and other parts of moths,
laboriously "glued" to the film strip with
mylar tape, become a luxuriant, brown-
tinged abstract animation during projection.
No camera is use; the film is "built" from life itself.   
SC

___________________________________________________________________________________________

THE ELIMINATION OF THE CAMERA

Another development, primarily associated with Len Lye
and Norman McLaren, has been the creation of films without
use of a camera.  Based on the painting or scratching of the
film emulsion by the artist (or, as in Brakhage's Mothlight, the
glueing of extraneous materials to the film strip), this technique
has created many beautiful abstract works.  In some, even the
sound is created without musical instruments merely by "scratching"
the soundtrack portion of the film strip in particular ways.
___________________________________________________________________________________________

OLYMPIAD
(Lillian Schwartz, USA, 1971)
A computer animation:  a single drawing
(instead of the 24 different drawings per second
needed in conventional animation) is stored in
the computer's memory and then programmed
into movement.  Every frame and transfor-
mation is done by the computer. The "result",
though programmed, is not entirely predictable.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

THE ELIMINATION OF THE ARTIST

The "unholy" convergence of early Soviet anti-individualism
(taken to extreme lengths by the contemporary Chinese
campaigns against "credits" for artistic accomplishments),
Duchamp's disappearance into reclusion, Warhol's repro-
duction of "originals" by factory methods, and the rise
of radical artists' collectives seem to many observers
increasingly to imply the dispensability of the artist.

The recent development of computer-generated films
(although programmed by humans) only serves to reaffirm
this possibility:  for at the very beginning of this curious new
art form, it is already clear that from initial programs and
memory banks computers can create (indeed, already have
created) orchestrated systems of aesthetically pleasing patterns
or realistic representations which arise before us in combinations
and complexities beyond our productive or absorptive faculties.

Equally startling are A.M. Noll's computer-generated films
of a 4-dimensional hypercube (mathematically projected
down into 3 dimensions and then projected in superimposition)
which, with slightly different picture for left and right eye,
create a powerful 3-dimensional effect without glasses.  (7)


REFERENCES

(1)   Michel Seuphor, Abstract Painting, 1964   (2)  Frank Whitford,
Expressionism, 1970 (3)  Piet Mondrian, "A New Realism", in  Plastic Art
and Pure Plastic Art, 1945 (4)  Rudolf Arnheim, Toward a Psychology of Art, 1966 (5)
 Gene Youngblood, Expanded Cinema, 1970   (6)  Youngblood (7)  Kenneth Knowlton,
"Computer-animated Movies",  in Cybernetic Serendipity, 1969


FILMS

RAZOR BLADES
(Paul Sharits, USA. 1968)
Hypnotic multi-screen avant-garde film, consisting of
unrelated, compulsively recurring images, a few frames
in length, interrupted by irregularly-spaced blank or color
frames or lettering.  A powerful rhythm and stroboscopic
flicker is created by insistent alterations of image and blank
frames. Each frame shown here is visibile for only 1/24th of
a second, inducing subliminal absorption of image clusters.
______________________________________________

This complex and controversial experiment utilizes two screens and
the simultaneous projection of two separate films working in tandem.
Each consists of unrelated, compulsively recurring images, not more
than a few frames in length, interrupted by carefully-spaced blank or
color frames.  A powerful overall rhythm and stroboscopic flicker is cre-
ated by the irregular but insistent alternations of image and blankness.
The result is a powerful subliminal barrage of strong sensory impressions
probing the audience's physiological and psychological limits.  Related
to neo-dada and pop, the film is strongly structuralist and reductive in
its avoidance of "meaning" or "plot", yet offers the satisfaction of pure
response to color, pattern, and -- particularly -- rhythm.  The images,
though intentionally without logic, are frequently "hot" and endlessly
repetitive: a fetus, a nude woman (with a razor passing over her), a penis
(flaccid or erect), some ambiguous toilet activity; equally  ritualistic is
the repeated appearance of single, senseless words printed over some
of the images. An agitated, monotonous electronic sound accompanies
the swiftly moving, constantly changing visuals and flicker patterns.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

ARNULF RAINER
(Peter Kubelka, Austria, 1957)
This is the first frame-by-frame
abstraction that entirely dispenses
with the image and consists solely of
carefully orchestrated alternations
of blank black or white frames.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

BALLET MECHANIQUE
(Fernand Leger, France, 1924)
Leger's only film, an avant-garde classic, fully anticipates
several preoccupations of the contemporary underground:
use of representational materials, while their documentary
aspects are destroyed by eliminating logic or plot; "subliminal"
images (only a few frames each); compulsive repetition of action
(almost ten times); the beauty of the fragmentary;  and the
abstraction of objects by close-ups, thus lending them a
new identity. Representational reality is left far behind.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

BELLS OF ATLANTIS
(Ian Hugo, USA, 1953)
A magical voyage into the subconcious in search of
"the lost continent" of first human memories. Based
on Anais Nin's prose poem, the film provides a visual
equivalent in subaqueous, drifting imagery taken
from reality but entirely transformed into a
new and sensuously poetic universe. Excellent
electronic score by Louis and Bebe Barron.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

LOOPS
(Norman McLaren, Canada, 1948)
A color, sound film made without camera
or musical instruments.  The images are hand-
painted onto 35mm film a frame at a time;  so is
the sound (dots running along edge of filmstrip,
size and thickness of dot determines its  itch).

___________________________________________________________________________________________

BEYOND THE LAW
(Norman Mailer, USA, 1968)  (F)
Mailer's outrageous film is a sardonic, mysterious drama
of detectives and suspects, locked in obscene and unequal
combat in a night-lit, not-so-mythical police station.
Suffused with implied or explicit violence, it poses a
daring triple paradox:  the brilliant capture of "reality"
through improvised dialogue and Pennebaker's cinema
verite photography; its almost instantaneous unmasking
as a fabrication (Mailer's appearance as an Irish police
lieutenant); its re-emergence as "social" truth.  As an
involved protagonist,  Mailer (similar to his role in "The
Armies of the Night") both participates in and changes
the event.  The (fictional) police lieutenant's marital
squabbles with (fictional) spouse are convincingly
portrayed by the real Mailer and his (then) real wife
in a further twist of the reality-illusion theme.
The gamblers, murderers, perverts and innocents
include Michael McClure, George Plimpton,
Rip Torn, and Jack Richardson.  A further
(and significant) chapter in the Mailer saga.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

BLAZES
(Robert Breer, USA. 1961)
4000 frames of film, featuring 100 basic images
in breathtakingly rapid sequence produce a single
kinetic impression.   As in Vertov's experiments,
two different images immediately following
each other on consecutive frames create
superimpositions that do not exist in reality.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

BLACK TV
(Aldo Tambellini, USA, 1969)
Videotape is used here as a personal and artistic medium:
documentary television images of today's violence are
distorted into rapid-fire, black-and-white abstractions,
Robert Kennedy's assassination, police brutality,
murder, infanticide, prizefights, and Vietnam
become blurred insistent symbols of today's horrors.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

BETWEEN TWO WORLDS
(Sam Kaner and Guy Cote, montage sequence
by Val Telberg, Great Britain, 1955)
The conventional image is exploded as super-
imposition achieves a magical look-through effect
which destroys the one-dimensional flatness of film,
creates a new universe beyond, and hints at death.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

DAMON THE MOWER
(George Dunning, Great Britain, 1971)
An original work of animation art.  Tacked onto a wall
are two sheets of drawing paper, on which appear, in
rapid, mysterious permutations, strange hand-drawn
images -- constantly undulating, exploding, reforming.
A recurrent motif -- a mower  with a scythe -- adds a
somber touch. The images, we are told, are in synchro-
nization with an inaudible poem removed from the
soundtrack. The effect of confining all "reality" in the
film to the sheets of drawing paper is extremely unsettling.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

FLICKER
(Tony Conrad, USA, 1966)
This film contains no images at all.  It's subject is light
and its absence. It consists of combinations of alternating
white and black frames, flashing by in constantly changing
patterns and causing a continuous stroboscopic flicker effect
of great complexity.  Whether its frequency is momentarily static
or changeable (it ranges from 24 flashes down to 4 flashes per second
throughout its 30 minute duration), the effect is literally hypnotic.
 This concerted "overload" of retina and nervous system provokes an
endless variety of changing shapes, patterns and, most surprisingly,
colors, whose nature differs with each viewer (even varying from
performance to performance).  The electronic  soundtrack was
generated by relays and components carrying different types of infor-
mation; the various frequencies are orchestrated by the director.
This  "pure"  film deals with perception itself; its hallucinatory
effect --  despite absence  of image, content,wor meaning --
reveals an unsuspected congruity with deep emotional needs. 
SC

___________________________________________________________________________________________

H 2 0
(Ralph Steiner, USA, 1929)
Though entirely based on elements of reality -- the
rhythms and patterns of light and shadow on water --
this classic study by the well-known documentary
filmmaker and still photographer approaches
pure abstraction, as the camera becomes
increasingly absorbed with textures and design.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

PAS DE DEUX
(Norman McLaren, Canada, 1968)
By printing the negative in multiple images,
each frame reproduced up to eleven times,
McLaren captures movement past and yet to
come in a rhapsodic flow of ineffable grace.
The simultaneous reproduction of consecu-
tive movement fulfills an age-old dream.
The dancers, in white and lit from behind,
move in slow-motion on a totally black stage.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

INNOCENCE UNPROTECTED
(NEVINOST BEZ ZASTITE)
(Dusan Makavejev, Yugoslavia, 1968)  (F)
The director of WR-Mysteries of the Organism in this earlier
film created a provocative and original collage which combined,
with subtle irony, the first Serbian sound film ever made ("an
outrageously naive melodrama of lecherous lust vs. true love" -
Sunday Times) with Nazi newsreels and 1968 interviews of
participants in the original production. The original 1942 Serbian
film was directed by its star, Dragoljub Aleksic, famed real-life
acrobat whose stunts -- seen in the film -- included changing
from flying planes by his teeth, transporting Belgrade ladies from
rooftop to rooftop by high wire, and bodily stopping motorcars
driven at top speed.  It deals with his  hair-raising adventures in
saving  an orphan heroine from the clutches of shameless and
repulsive characters after breathtaking feats of daring.  A sly and
loving film, it forces us to take this persistent man and his bizarre
values almost as seriously as he does, thus making us more humble
about our own.  It successfully destroys conventional concepts
of  time and reality in its mingling of two films -- from different
periods --  one fictional, the other non-fictional -- with the
actors of the former constantly breaking its illusion by
appearing in the latter in real-life portraits 20 years later.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

INSTITUTIONAL QUALITY
(George Landow, USA, 1969)
An empty, ordinary room in an apartment.  There is furniture,
a lamp, a television set.  No image is visible on it, except the
changing variations of light on its screen, indicating that
the set is on.  At the narrator's request, a large hand -- live --
enters the frame with a pencil and numbers portions of what
is now suddenly revealed not to have been a real room at
all, but a projected "image" of a room, a film within a film.
The sudden superimposition of a live hand over what we had
accepted as reality is one of the more unsettling moments of
contemporary minimal cinema. Later we see a young woman
threading a projector, as instructed by the same invisible narrator;
suddenly a subtitle informs us (in terms familiar on television)
that  this is a "re-enactment".  Since the scene is by definition a
fictional portrayal of a situation and cannot be considered a "re-
enactment"  (of what?) this constitutes a subtle toying with levels
of reality and an attack, as is the rest of the film, on screen illusion.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

THE MAN WHO LEFT HIS WILL ON FILM
(TOKYO SENSO SENGO HIWA)
(Nagisa Oshima, Japan, 1970)  (F)
Aesthetic and political rebel, Oshima is one of the most original
directors now working in Japan.  This is a metaphysical tale of a
radical student filmmaker who succumbs to the illusion that he has
committed suicide and left a film as his testament. Attempting to
"decipher" this film and the "dead man's" life, he rapes his own
girl (who plays along with the illusion to cure him) and retraces
the "other man's" life by means of the film, only to find himself in
his own birthplace.  The film testament proves incomprehensible.
He therefore refilms it, intending to create a work superior to that
of his illusory rival; but his girl, to save him, willfully interrupts and
changes each scene.  He finally realizes that he must kill the dead
man --  himself -- in order to be free.  Several key episodes, including
sex scenes, are recreated by the protagonists in front of a screen
showing the film testament so that they are projected onto their bodies.
Throughout, the style is meticulously realistic, meticulously metaphysical.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

N.Y., N.Y.
(Francis Thompson, USA, 1958)
Distortion lenses, spheric and parabolic mirrors, and
prisms create a semi-abstract, atomized, and sub-
jective version of the city, in which buildings float in
space and man has become an alienated, distorted
mass-being.  The effect is startling and disturbing.
______________________________________________

"An admirable example of what may be called the
Distorted Documentary -- a new form of visionary art.
 In this very strange and beautiful picture we see the city
of  New York as it appears when photographed through
multiple prisms, or reflected in the backs of spoons,
polished hub caps, spherical and parabolic mirrors.
We still recognize houses, people, shop fronts, taxicabs,
but recognize them as elements in one of those living
geometries which are so characteristic of the visionary
experience. I was amazed to see that virtually ever
pictorial device invented by the old masters of
non-representational art makes its appearance,
alive, glowing, intensely  significant."  --
Aldous Huxley, "Heaven and Hell"

___________________________________________________________________________________________

PERMUTATIONS
(John Whitney, USA, 1968)
A brilliant computer-generated study by one of
America's foremost pioneers of abstract cinema.
 "It is now known and amply demonstrated that computer-
graphic systems are useful in the creation of a considerable
diversity of abstract graphic forms.  It can be shown that the
precision and detail of the graphics and the power of the com-
puter to repeated thousands of images, each one with the most
subtle incremental variation, makes for an instrument with
superb motion-generating capability.  This power of the computer
to produce endless variations upon patterns, which stems from the
basically mathematical foundation by which all images are formed,
means that we have at hand an instrument for graphics that is
analogous to the variational power of all musical instruments and
the mathematical foundation of all musical form." - John Whitney

___________________________________________________________________________________________

PERSONA
(Ingmar Bergman, Sweden, 1965-66)  (F)
"As the title tells us this film is about reality and illusion --
the persona of a person indicating the latter, the root of the
word being old Latin for mask.  Parallel to the story  (perhaps
horizontal to it would be a better description), Bergman also
shows us that film itself (when it refers to itself as this one does)
is also about reality and illusion.  The illusion is the filmed story,
the two women, their relationship, the husband of one  of them, etc.
 The reality (or a reality at any rate) is the fact that it is a film we
are watching. This is proved to us by the inclusion of film leader,
shots of a film lab, a shot of the making-of-the-film itself, scenes
of the film we are seeing running through a projector, and sections
where the film is apparently ripped, where a frame apparently catches
fire and burns.  At the very end of the film (a scene which "proves"
it has been a film we are watching), we see the arc-lamp of the
projector going out -- a parallel to the first (and last) word that
the personified heroine speaks:  'Nothing'. "  - Donald Ritchie  
SC

___________________________________________________________________________________________

FANTASTIC VISION
(Eugene Deslaw, Spain/Switzerland, year unknown)
The first solarized film ever made.  The elimination
of realistic detail and sharp outlines while preser-
ving legibility creates a strongly poetic image.
 The contemporary avant-garde has  returned to
this device in a technologically more sophis-
ticated manner with breathtaking results.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

THE SECRET CINEMA
(Paul Bartel, USA, 1966)
Through a series of hilarious yet increasingly disturbing
incidents, a young girl becomes convinced she suffers
from a paranoid delusion that her life is being secretly
filmed and projected in separate chapters at a local movie
house.  In an extremely clever play on illusion and reality,
she -- and we -- discover that she is right.  Beneath the
flippant facade an uncomfortable black comedy unfolds,
as the filmmaker deftly manipulates our subconcious;
for the plight of the hapless heroine, confused, paranoid,
surrounded by people who seldom are what they seem
to be, corresponds to our own deepest fears. 
SC

___________________________________________________________________________________________

UFO'S
(Lillian Schwartz and Ken Knowlton, USA, 1972)
This film further indicates that computer animation --
once a gimmick -- is fast becoming a fully-fledged art;
the complexity of its design and movement, its speed
and rhythm, richness of form and motion -- coupled
with stroboscopic effects to affect brain waves --
is quite overpowering. What is even more ominous
is  that while design and action are programmed,
the "result", in any particular sequence, is neither
entirely predictable nor under complete human
control, being created at a rate faster (and in conca-
tenations more complex) than eye and mind can follow
or initiate.  Our sense of reality is thus disturbed not only
by the filmmaker by also by the machines we have produced.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

TUP-TUP
(Nedejlko Dragic, Yugoslavia, 1972)
An astonishing incursion of modern art into the
animated film: one of the characters "breaks"
through to another reality, thereby subverting
the illusionism of the image and calling into
question what must never be doubted:  the absolute
"truth" of the image as the only existing reality.